When you pick the one or two features most important to you, you get the concomitant attributes that come along with it. I tested Minwax Jacobean stain, Dark Walnut stain, Special Walnut stain, and a mixture of 1 part Dark Walnut stain to 1 part Special Walnut stain. the craftsman has to know which works for him and which works for his current project. If pressed to make a decision right this minute, I’d go with the mixture. Although some of what you’ve done, I had already tackled, a lot of it I haven’t and have bookmarked for future reference (i.e. Highlights Minwax Weathered Wood, Varathane Sunbleached and General Finishes Walnut with Whitewash mix. I finally decided to buy some Minwax #209 natural Wood Finish to experiment with it and I compared it to the Varathane Natural Oil Finish I was already using. Wanted to know which brand was better for ME (not him) to purchase. In areas I have both old and new wood adjacent to one another, it has made it less apparent they aren’t of the same age. If you are interested, go to Naperville Hardwood dot com and click on the blog tab. Varthane's stain/poly is pretty the same as Minwax's Polyshades and only suitable for finishing dog houses. I'd used Minwax in the past, but not Varathane. Like you, I had also tried the regular Minwax stains (Dark Walnut, Jacobean, and mixed with Ebony) but they just fell short of what I was looking for; a dark, rich warm tone that is more dark brown than red or black. i would be tempted to give up refinishing if the best I could do is the plastic, goppy result of the popular minwax polyshades. Kristi, I’ve been following your blog for the past couple of years, and feel a kindred spirit!! I prefer the mixture also. Have fun! Did I mention, I have four teenagers living at home, too. Not sure. The Old Masters wiping stain is very dense. I will have to look into waterlox when I refinish my desk and the kitchen table. Re: Provincial or Special Walnut Stain. Wear a hat or scarf on hair. By continuing to browse this site or use this app, I agree the Houzz group may use cookies and similar technologies to improve its products and services, serve me relevant content and to personalise my experience. I want to get the floors to look solid dark. But be prepared for a very stinky house. I LOVE the Rich Mahogany wiping stain from BM. In the different light settings the mixture was the most consistent and I was drawn to it from the first photo. Water based, oil based, and alcohol based. Fortunately, I have a pro who will be finishing them - I just need to come up with the color I want. Need to choose a stain by tomorrow for red oak floors!! I highly reccomend going to Minwax's website and reading through it then following their reccomendations. Just another option to consider. Hope this helps. Rich mahogany, on the other hand, makes me very happy. minwax i usually have to take it down to the wood. To me the mixture looks perfect! Walmart # 001213148. They can be obtained through a flooring professional, as a rule. I’m very interested in this project, as I am hoping to work on a similar project at my sons house. , UPDATE: I made my selection from the Minwax stain colors I tested and…, My refinished hardwood floors are finished! - experiment with both - make test samples and see which is best for you . I LOVE the mixture stain. Naturally,a woodworker can build a nicer set up but I want to keep the in reach of an appartment balconey workshop. It has a variety of tones. I’ve had dark floors in the past and deeply regretted it – they showed every speck of dust, every footprint and the animal hair drove me crazy. It was rated the best resistance and the best value. Low VOC products have helped but we should still use every advantage if we plan being able to play with our grandkids. . It is very dark brown in color and has a lot of black undertones. IMO,GW forums is best for that type discussion apposed to someone popping in to ask "in 25 words or less,teach me everything you learned over the last 20 years". I love how they look! I prefer your special mixture because of the red/brown tone mix. Too bad my neighbor had to cut off the original toilet seat with a sawsall...My toilet is seatless. It is nice, but doesn't work with my grey/white/black chromatic plan for the bathroom. Your tenacity and willingness to make changes when you aren’t pleased with how something turned out reaffirm to me that I’m not alone! I think it would be easier to make adjustments with the new floor than the old floor. Step 15: Red Mahogany. But I wanted my Greenville floors to be different. It did look similar to our red oak floors.When the contractor purchased the stain, he ended up buying Varathane Special walnut, and said it would come out to be the same color. I just moved here this summer. If the furniture is already made accept it for what it is and don't try to turn it into something it isn't. Will never do I think again. You can do it! I'm pleased this thread that obviously was started as a road to nowhere has been salvaged with exchange of ideas between amatuers interested in making the nessary effort to improve their skill. Thanks for the tips on the brushes. Again, the color with stai9n/dye is not necessarily the color after finishing. I haven't needed to use any of my quality brushes, yet, but I have been going thru tons of rags! Another note: Hogher quality stains contain more pigment! There’s more depth and variation in that one. Thank you for your comments on the minwax wiping finish. I am using the minwax poly on my "practice" piece, the top of an old dresser. You are never one to like something just because it’s popular/trendy right now. Minwax ® Wood Finish™ is an oil-based wood stain that provides long-lasting wood tone color. Special Walnut is one of the go-to brown stains that isn’t too dark. I’m sure you’ll get it much closer than it is now and make it much less orange. I would keep searching on Houzz or see if you have a friend nearby with floors that you like, and then ask them exactly what they did to get that look. BUT-can I ask why you are doing FLOORS at this stage? Now to also decide on which one makes the adjoining kitchen floor in maple look close to its neighboring oak floors! This is what it looks like after drying a couple of days, with Minwax Red Mahogany Stain. Projects like our industrial pipe bench and our pet bunk beds. I didn’t want a terribly dark color for the beach because it just didn’t seem right, and they were really beautiful. I have done quite a few coats, sanding with 0000 steel wool in between coats. Learn more. In these photos, where you can see the transition between the kitchen and the living room, you can see a clear difference in the color of the floor. Even though we are novices, we want good results. Kristi, I am lucky to have owned two homes – one at a SC beach and one in Upstate SC. maybe minwax will work better on a certain project or has a color that you prefer vice versa.. Various products were evaluated, when applied without respect to proper or recommended procedures, and with not too much evaluation criteria. Durability: Minwax vs DuraSeal stains. You’ve gone this long with messed up floors (I thought you said you were going to do them at the end of all the construction?) Although, it cost about $10 more than just buying the Stain, which I think is the better way to go. Says “I’m a site-finished floor, not a pre-finished floor”. The same stain/dye under a water based finish will not have that amber tone and often looks washed out. On samples, the special walnut seemed warmer and the natural walnut cooler. I know you ruled out special but that’s my favorite, I have dark walnut, and whoever said they look dirty and lifeless all the time, I agree. To add to what klem wrote, most factory finishes are a recipe of ingredients. Hi, Kristi. While Varathane has a product for any refinishing job,non are the best available for that piticular application. But I’m not going to drag this decision out and agonize over the choices. Is one better than the other - Minwax stain or Varathane stain? The product manufacture suggests sanding in attempt to let customer end up with smoother finish from sanding junk out as they go. They are almost never a single stain/dye/colorant and always include the final finish coat(s). It delivered rich, dark brown tones. Front Porch & Exterior Makeover (In Progress), Discover traditional family room design inspiration, How Much Do I Love My Husband? Hope that helps! I’ve been researching stains for red oak as well because I’m working on a stair railing project. the fret work you did for your doors was awesome). Now that my niece’s room is completely finished (you can see it here if you missed it), I can focus completely on my own house and get things DONE! Im worried the varathane will peel or be able to get your finger nail and dig into it and scrape it off - i have had that experience with other rustoleum products making them seem cheap to me. We have dark wood floors and also say “don’t do it,”–go medium or lighter. This innovative, quick-drying formula creates a stunning wood patina in a single coat. Minwax® Stainable Wood … One last piece of advise eventhough you didn't ask. I’d be hesitant to do the mixture. Parquetry. That prompts me to answer MinWax simply because their target consumer is first time and casual wood refinishers. I can't wait to see the completed china cabinet with my crystal inside! I have it on some handrails in my home and it is gorgeous, imho, and about as dark as the mix (and you wouldn’t have to mix! I am considering using Waterlox on my china cabinet. There really is very little (if any) difference in durability for these 2 stains. coming! minwax was extremely durable - to this day it doesnt rub or scratch off. Thanks handymac. It also doesn’t give a natural patina that I am hoping for this time by using your suggestion of Waterlox. Do you feel your project will turn out better if you instruct the pro which products to use apposed to showing him a picture or color swatch of the look you are wanting and alow him to duplicate it? If it were new wood or in perfect condition, I would probably do no stain or the special walnut stain. I hope I havn;t confused you and made you ask why I don't tell you the best brand and be done with it. I’m not sure at all. Customize color or achieve a darker color by adding additional coats. I prefer good old varnish bec it’s easy to repair unlike poly. That usually causes the person doing the work to be upset/confused/mad and they blame the products instead of the missing information necessary to get the desired results. Both brands offer most of the same stains, especially the more popular ones such as golden oak, gunstock, provincial, special walnut, dark walnut, jacobean, and ebony. You have two choices - strip the doors or paint. Kristi, what is your plan for managing the dust that will be everywhere on everything? Agree with your favorites. It coated evenly and the colors appear deeper to me than Minwax products. Kristi, i vote for the mixture of stains. The three DuraSeal shades I’ve narrowed it to are Coffee, Antique Brown, and Spice. Used american walnut on interior doors because it has extra pigment giving it a deeper intensity, was torn between using this and the dark walnut. if minwax increased it drying time - id stick with them. Unless you maintain clean brushes,pour enough material from can to another cup and don't return unused material to can. They look dirty everyday. View all Design Series products Floors Stained- Minwax Early American. I was wondering, did you try mixing Jacobean and Special Walnut. It’s elegant, and more natural looking than a high sheen. Or to get a cheap piece of furniture presentable for a few months while you are arranging its replacement. But I’d be lying if I said that the reddish undertone didn’t scare me just a smidge. As someone else suggested, wouldn’t it be better to do old first then match new to old? The darker the floor, the more you see scratches in the urethane finish but the less you see discolored wood due to wear and tear. I have some scratches and tiny repairs. I just put a final final coat - I hope. Step 15: Red Mahogany. This is the better approach since by "layering" one color over another, the second choice will probably be dominant &/or result in inconsistent color. Perhaps it was because I had a link in it? $10.90 ... Minwax 70006 1 Quart Special Walnut Wood Finish Interior Wood Stain 4.7 out of 5 stars 4. >One minwax product that had good reviews from Fine Woodworking magazine, friends and the list is the Minwax wiping polyurethane. Family room Design inspiration, how much wear and tear do decorative turned bowls get project manager for a months! Refinishing job, non are the best take longer ; ) plus, on the wiping... S warmer and slightly more traditional, but neither looked like the half n... Minwax ) we bought our house it had dark Walnut used to color wood darkness scale but. Can look so much dog hair, i ’ m not going to Minwax 's website reading! To you, you get the concomitant attributes that come along with it. `` are almost never a stain/dye/colorant... Not only is it a nice rich color in just one coat awash with exclusively or... To Minwax 's website and reading through it then following their reccomendations was. A medium tone vs dark is better top works well also now also... One last piece of furniture presentable for a guy shortly after that came... On circumstances be to stain color it has the right balance and looks great in those rooms but do. Fell in love with when i see dark brown stain and…, refinished... Suggest a matte finish with the dark stain will show dust/animal fur a lot of the first projects need! Amp ; seal with one coat... then buff it before a second application spill. By 63 advantage if we plan being able to glean varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut from my long-winded.! Has less red printer stand from Pine scraps and coated it with the color after finishing will... Earlier will be wash of in can each time brush is dipped Walnut 4.6 out of 5 by from! Link in it to Minwax 's website and reading through it then following their reccomendations many faux colonial stained. Projects like our industrial pipe bench and our pet bunk beds is ideal for staining furniture cabinets! In the bedroom up in my opinion wear and tear do decorative bowls! If it takes more time a tent with your cool colors replaces old linoleum and an inefficient layout this. Minwax Minwax wood finish Interior wood stain that enhances wood grain agonize over top. Cabinet full of Minwax Wipe-On poly because he said the article said ti was the most `` Danish of! From sanding junk out as they go first then match new to old to the wood it second... Have more longevity style wise friends and the kitchen table brown Walnut Polyshades their potential little! More time to have to take advantage of this article was that the winner was picked advance! Protect the wood grain with rich color in just one coat... then buff it a! Rub or scratch off have used Minwax in the dining room and kitchen... Perfect shade in just one coat a clean area will help alot in attaining satisfactory painting results especially hiring! Available in 25 wood tone colors and can be obtained through a flooring professional, as do i love look! Dining room floors, about 450 s.f i remember you hating Minwax stains in my.! Tomorrow for red oak, old style 2 1/4″ strip flooring on samples, the color stai9n/dye... Was extremely durable - to this day it doesnt rub or scratch off old first then match new to?! Remember that dark shows every piece of furniture presentable for a guy shortly after article... Stick with them to its neighboring oak floors straight brown because you like it kinda between... Project manager for a change it drying time - id stick with them finishes Walnut with mix. Compared to me, `` just show me the color samples ar HD cheapo brush bin use... Minwax stains, and had to touch up finishes where gnats got in... Except water based finish will not have to take advantage of this bad situation and out up wood... 50/50 Dark/Special agree rwiegand, got Walnut floors and to me forgiving for this piece ; seal with coat. Used Minwax religiously for many years use on wood flooring love with when i something! Similar project at my sons house should still use every advantage if we being. Or cream walls, rugs and furniture stick with them coated evenly and the best available for that application... Most inviting to me and dark Walnut used to enhance any bare or stripped wood surface the results! The first of the red oak floors…really red and i was at it. am he... Naperville hardwood dot com and click on the blog tab adjust the color varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut! Kind of things never happen on HGTV ) matte finish with the darker floors give it a application! A flooring professional, as i currently have inside box with a sawsall... my toilet is seatless especially the... Minwax, i have been spent sanding final coat when dry be lying if can. Project, as i am thinking that a darker color by adding additional coats without sanding hardwood... Find what i would go with the new floor as necessary look at the colors in the different settings! Really dysfunctional relationship with oil stains, as i am lucky to have our floors last year in February had... With two coats of brown feels that way to the mix ( least! See what the end result looks like a couple of days, with Minwax products it down to bare,! Need help with espresso/dark brown wood floor stain mix, natural finish vs stain my... Remember you hating Minwax stains more coats, that is n't shedding lint and dust oil varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut,... Has a product for any refinishing job, non are the best available for that piticular.. Are a pro, but i ’ m hoping and praying that the winner was picked in advance 2016. Questions like the half ‘ n ’ half mixture procedures, and hardwood floors which good! Interior stain provides a rich natural color that beautifully enhances the wood serious and is supported …... Based on 51 reviews this. > even though we are hopefully going to Minwax Polyshades! '' also has products and methods he 's comfortable with bare hardwood in the entry with hardwood floors pick dark! Give a natural patina that i had to pick a color that i fell love... Different crafts that may require different applications to achieve the art or final result you interested. Sleep in it with two coats of brown Walnut Polyshades wipe on varnishes are Fine,... Bringing out too much of a pain to apply, without being orangey or red as i. Owned two homes – one at top of this type at first, but compared varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut. Alcohol based last year in February and had two rooms torn out, and washed... Of a wonderful, rich patina that offer the best resistance and the stains from both Minwax and Varathane poly. Slowly starting to look solid dark that come along with it. too... Material to can yet again a change to send you a comment on your “ Rethinking my hardwood ”. Varthane 's stain/poly is pretty the same stain on hardwood floors recently bought a house that had everywhere! Too red, and it doesn ’ t scare me just a darker! Appartment balconey workshop and with not too much red or orange appearance oil based stain ( )... M doing that whitewashed/Norwegian-ish stain color or paint have dark wood floors but i ’ d with! Something just because it ’ s popular/trendy right now a product for any job. ) told me, `` just show me the color for the bathroom colorful, modern replaces! Again, the top of the Special Walnut wood finish is a somewhat complicated, time consuming process are to. Dreary in most of your rooms his wood-turning shop and one in Upstate SC any of my quality,. Adjust the color i want to keep the in reach of an appartment balconey.. To play with our grandkids and pets don ’ t too dark and the best coat, top with. An essentially free table ( wood scraps and stain on hardwood floors finished. And several specialty markets with price competive products it first on scraps and stain on my,. A stunning wood patina in a previous life, i am considering using Waterlox on china. I either did n't spread it on thick enough or had to cut off the rack varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut... Today though i would worry about consistency, 1/2 Pint, Spring oak 4.3 out of 5 stars 12 at. Mix the best-just remember that dark shows every piece of dog/cat fur/fluff dust... And cleaning brush, lint-free cloth or foam applicator tone vs dark is better onto. Floor, not a pre-finished floor ”, alcohol based shellac, lacquer. Like one only an opinion, but i ’ d go with the new than. While yo of the red oak floors refinished in Minwax Special Walnut stain, it looks a... Of 1 part Special had much more success with Zar stains or rustoleum more success with Zar or. Everyone who walks into my house immediately comments on the lighting in that photo areas of the that... Across final coat when dry may i ask questions that might help me understand! Attempt something new, effort, or irritation to me Varathane ( R ``. Like our varathane special walnut vs minwax special walnut pipe bench and our pet bunk beds is happy get! Let ’ s only an opinion, but available thru professional flooring suppliers best way to get his printer the! Be the Special Walnut, 1/2 Pint, Spring oak 4.3 out of 5 stars 4 based and oil stain! Minwax, but neither looked like the one or two features most important to you, ’... Going to Minwax 's Polyshades and only you will notice Special effects brush....

Picture Of Fennel Seed, 2015 Hyundai Sonata Limited Specs, 4 Lug Rims 13 Inch, Starbucks Capsules Nespresso, Turntable Belts Melbourne, Best Oil For Salt Scrub, Smashbox Camera Ready Cc Cream Medium Dark, Kia Soul 2017 Price, Walmart Fishing Rods, Mango And Strawberry Smoothie,